INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM · RALEIGH COUNTY, WEST VIRGINIA

THE RALEIGH RECORD

RALEIGH COUNTY JUDICIAL & LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT

THE POLING BOOTH — THE ORIGINAL ORDERS, THE CONTRADICTORY FILINGS, AND THE SOURCES

DOCUMENT-FIRST UPDATE, OCTOBER 18, 2026. We retrieved the original November 4 order and December 3 fraud-sanctions order, plus an actual stamped page of the April disqualification filing. These original court pages now sit beside the judge’s full April response and carefully labeled working Word excerpts from the litigant’s earlier filings. Original filed source and uncertified editable working copy are never treated as interchangeable.

RECORD COMPARISON 1 — APRIL 14 MOTION VERSUS JUDGE POLING’S APRIL 21 RESPONSE

APRIL 14 · COURT-STAMPED ORIGINAL MOTION — FIRST PAGE

Clerk stamp establishes April 14, 2026 at 8:59 AM, C-328. Original first page only; the full 49-page filed submission is not yet authenticated for public posting.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

APRIL 21 · COMPLETE FOUR-PAGE JUDICIAL RESPONSE

Full April response. Paragraph 2 says the motion does not identify specific improper acts by Poling; paragraphs 3–5 criticize incomplete citations; paragraph 6 says no hearing was ever requested.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

APRIL MOTION’S POLING-SPECIFIC ALLEGATIONS & FULL CASE CITATIONS — WORKING WORD COPY

Selected exact passages from the supplied editable Word file: Rule 2.11(A), Caperton, Brown, Mathews, Murchison, Tumey, and specific criticisms of Poling’s November and December orders. This is NOT the certified interior text of the April 14 stamped filing.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

THE EXAMINATION: Poling’s April 21 paragraph 2 states Jackson never identified what Poling did wrong. The matching working April text names the November 4 refiling order, December 3 fraud-evidence denial, failure-to-hear allegations, and other specific conduct. That is a powerful document-content discrepancy conditional on authenticating the filed interior pages. A judge may conclude those grounds are legally insufficient; saying no specific acts were identified is a different factual proposition. OPEN THE FULL RULE 17 DOCUMENT LIBRARY →

RECORD COMPARISON 2 — NOVEMBER 4: “ANY CASELAW” VERSUS THE CITATIONS IN THE OCTOBER MATERIALS

JUDGE POLING · NOVEMBER 4, 2025 — ORIGINAL ORDER

The original signed order says the plaintiff failed properly to cite any discussed or relied-upon case law in the pending motions, then requires reconstruction and refiling of motions and replies.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

JACKSON · OCTOBER 2025 IFP REPLY — EDITABLE WORKING SOURCE EXCERPT

An expressly uncertified extract from the supplied ZIP’s October IFP reply contains full case citations: Earley, Shenandoah Sales, Rowland, Sally–Mike, Moss, Smith, Kay, and others. The exact filed PDF corresponding to the clerk’s October entry remains necessary.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

THE EXAMINATION: No cited law, case names lacking reporter citations, and authorities deemed inapplicable are three different findings. An original October filing bearing the same fully reported cases would undercut the breadth of any universal no-citations characterization. The current Word copy identifies a substantial exception but is not yet proof of every citation in the filed docket version. The separate November master rewrite must not be silently backdated to an earlier filing.

RECORD COMPARISON 3 — DECEMBER 3 FRAUD-EVIDENCE DENIAL: READ THE ACTUAL ORDER

JUDGE POLING · DECEMBER 3, 2025 — COMPLETE TWO-PAGE ORIGINAL ORDER

The judge states he listened to the recording, says it contained no information about the date or calling party, and characterized the material as opinions rather than a legal basis for sanctions. This order must be compared against the original source-package receipt, declarations and complete submission; confidential recording materials have not been made public.

PDF preview unavailable. Open the document below.

OPEN / DOWNLOAD SOURCE PDF ↗

WHAT IS NOT ESTABLISHED: The order itself says the judge listened, so the publication must not claim he refused to hear the recording. The unresolved issue is whether he accurately described the entire original submitted package, including details, authenticated recording, transcript and declarations. The original Ramey response and evidence-receipt documents remain in the private review set pending public-release screening.

THE CRITICAL REMAINING SOURCE GAPS

Still required before this is a complete authenticated public investigation: (1) all interior pages and actual attachment set of the clerk-stamped April 14 motion; (2) the October C-328 docketed PDF and the then-pending filings affected by the November 4 order; (3) the original September 30 Rule 17 attachment manifest; (4) the actual August 25, 2025 consolidated-case separation order; (5) the publicly releasable version of Ramey’s November response and the fraud evidence receipt; (6) the complete response-by-response index of all supplied litigation files. These gaps are not described as proven suppression or as records already published.

Source authenticity matters: An adverse legal conclusion is not automatically a false statement, and a contradiction in an editable reconstruction is not automatically proof of falsehood in a certified original. This investigation is built to determine exactly what was before the court when its representations were made.

THE ORIGINAL EVIDENCE — NOT JUST OUR REPORTING

Start with these original court documents. Click the PDFs, read the words and compare the dates. On smaller screens, the files appear one above the other.

RULE 17: WHAT HE SAID IN APRIL VERSUS WHAT HE ACKNOWLEDGED IN SEPTEMBER

APRIL 21: Original signed filing-and-service representation

Embedded preview unavailable.

OPEN SOURCE FILE ↗

SEPTEMBER 30: Original acknowledgment of earlier e-filing omission (response excerpt)

Embedded preview unavailable.

OPEN SOURCE FILE ↗

OPEN THE FULL RULE 17 SOURCE-BY-SOURCE INVESTIGATION →

INDIGENCY: THE OPPOSING PARTY’S MOTION VERSUS THE COURT’S LATER ORDER

OCTOBER: Original defense motion, first two pages only

Embedded preview unavailable.

OPEN SOURCE FILE ↗

AUGUST 24: Original Poling court order

Embedded preview unavailable.

OPEN SOURCE FILE ↗

OPEN THE INDIGENCY FILE COMPARISON → · OPEN THE FOUNDATIONAL ORDER ANALYSIS →

PROVENANCE: The April and September Rule 17 source sets contain original photographed court documents assembled into public PDF view copies. The September response extract is not labeled as complete. Protected financial exhibits and confidential related-case files are withheld.

UNDER CONSTRUCTION — SIGNIFICANT ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE FORTHCOMING

The Poling Booth is open as a developing documentary investigation, not a completed evidentiary archive. Much more source material remains to be examined and added. Some of the most consequential and potentially most damaging evidence identified by the petitioner has not yet been published. The current page represents only part of the record and should not be read as a final determination of any person’s conduct.

Allegations are identified as allegations. Any disputed facts, responses, orders, and material counterevidence should be considered alongside the cited records. Any confidential Family Court, protective-order, or sealed materials remain withheld. Public-source comparisons are not findings of misconduct.

THE RALEIGH RECORD · INAUGURAL INVESTIGATION · PUBLIC WORKING EDITION

THE POLING BOOTH

Record vs. Record.

This page does not ask you to accept an allegation. It puts the judicial statement beside the filing, docket entry, order, or recorded communication that tests it.

READ BOTH. DECIDE WHAT THE RECORD SHOWS.

THE POLING BOOTH — PUBLIC INVESTIGATIVE INDEX

Public access is now open to the existing Poling research files and documentary analyses. The collection remains under substantial development. The available comparisons concern official judicial statements and orders, motion and hearing records, the Rule 17 administrative process, evidence restrictions, and judicial-disqualification questions. Original supporting documents that require confidentiality or redaction review are withheld; the publicly available court-order analyses and procedural chronology remain accessible. None of these articles establishes any allegation as proven.

Research dossiers and primary comparison pages

Published source analyses and developing reports

Publication note: This index represents what has been released from the existing site drafts, not an exhaustive evidentiary archive. Original source files, date cutoffs, later docket developments, and material rebuttal evidence will be reconciled as further work proceeds.

1. “NEVER CONTACTED THIS COURT TO REQUEST A HEARING.”

POLING · APRIL 21, 2026

Jackson “has never contacted this Court to request a hearing on any of his motions.”

Rule 17 response ¶6

THE EARLIER RECORD

Sept. 11, 2025: preserved chambers call records Jackson asking whether pending matters could be “scheduled for hearings.”

Nov. 20 · #75: express evidentiary-hearing request.

Nov. 24 · #77: another evidentiary-hearing request.

The issue is not whether Poling had to grant those requests. The issue is whether “never” accurately described the earlier record.

Trace the requests on the docket →

2. “NO LEGAL OR ETHICAL BASIS.”

THE RESPONSE

Poling said Jackson had not supplied a legal or ethical basis warranting disqualification.

THE MOTION AND MEMORANDUM

Jackson’s working authority index identifies approximately 32 constitutional, ethical, procedural, and decisional authorities, including Trial Court Rule 17.01, Judicial Conduct Rule 2.11(A), state disqualification authorities, U.S. Supreme Court due-process cases and Fourth Circuit authority.

Rejecting cited law is adjudication. Saying no legal basis was supplied is a description of what the filing contained. Those are different questions.

The final publication will link the filed motion, memorandum, authority index and Rule 17 response together after exact-version reconciliation.

3. THE HEARING THAT WAS SET — AND CONTINUED INDEFINITELY

November 4, 2025: Poling entered an order continuing a November 5 hearing indefinitely so he could review recently filed motions and related Kirby orders.

OPEN THE ORDER AND SEARCHABLE TEXT →

Later written requests for evidentiary development remained part of the record. The investigative question is not whether every motion deserved a hearing; it is how the later categorical and motion-specific hearing statements fit the documented sequence.

THE DISPOSITION GAP

“DISPOSED BY SEPARATE ORDER.”

The docket says there was an order. The reviewed source set still has not identified it.

May 8, 2026 · #93: verified motion seeking Rule-to-Show-Cause relief, evidentiary hearings, sanctions, preservation and related relief.

Aug. 24 · #134: the docket marks #93 “Disposed By Separate Order.”

What is missing: the separate order itself—its date, reasoning, findings and service history.

Until the order is found, The Raleigh Record will not invent what it decided.

4. THE FILING THAT WAS ACCEPTED — BUT NOT CLEARLY FINISHED

After Poling denied leave to submit a much longer reply, Jackson filed a dramatically shorter consolidated response on July 17, 2026 · #118. It opposed Abrams’s requested prefiling injunction, renewed the earlier show-cause request, asserted two additional show-cause grounds, sought a stay, and asked for additional relief.

The docket later separately disposes the original May 8 motion and the mandamus petition. In the source chronology reviewed here, #118 itself is not separately marked disposed in its entirety.

That distinction matters because one filing contained several independent requests for relief.

5. THE HEARING / EVIDENCE LOOP

Nov. 20: hearing requested.

Nov. 24: hearing requested again.

May 8: Rule to Show Cause and evidentiary development requested.

July 17: request renewed in #118.

July 24 · #121: “immediate evidentiary hearing” requested.

Sept. 3: the judicial-notice order notes that no evidence had been presented because no hearings had occurred.

Sept. 4: a separate order directs that future proposed evidence be presented and ruled upon at a properly scheduled hearing before entry in the file, while preserving the right to request a hearing.

The question: if hearings were repeatedly requested, how did the later hearing-dependent evidence process work in practice?

READ THE SEPTEMBER ORDERS SIDE-BY-SIDE →

6. FIRST RULE 17: WHAT WAS SENT? WHAT WAS FILED? WHAT WAS SERVED?

The April 21 transmittal materials create three separate record questions: what reached the Chief Justice, what appeared in the local circuit-court dockets, and what was served on Jackson and counsel. Those are not the same event.

The later July filing/service record and the August renewed Rule 17 process provide comparators. The publication will show the email, cover letter, judicial response, docket, certificate and administrative order together—not turn a service-date question into a motive accusation.

OPEN THE RULE 17 FILE →

7. THE PAGE-LIMIT ESCALATION

July 8: Poling denied leave to file an oversized reply and directed a compliant response.

July 17: Jackson filed the shorter #118 response.

Aug. 25: Poling established a prospective procedure for future filings exceeding page limits, including attachments, requiring advance authorization.

Sept. 4: the court separately restricted attachment of proposed evidence and required hearing-based admissibility review before the evidence would enter the file.

This is not one order. It is a sequence. The site will show each document in order.

READ THE SOURCE ANALYSIS →

DOCUMENTARY COMPARISON: THE AUGUST 10 EXHIBIT AND THE AUGUST 24 ORDER

August 10, 2026 · Defendant’s response to Plaintiff’s oversized consolidated reply, paragraph 9. Counsel argued that the proposed amended complaint “includes product liability claims.” The response also asserted that the proposed new defendants had nothing to do with the personal-protection proceeding underlying the original complaint. Counsel attached a proposed amended complaint as Exhibit A.

Defendant’s own Exhibit A · paragraph 51. The attached complaint expressly provided that vehicle-related claims were reserved and were not pleaded or submitted for adjudication in that action. The document itself was dated October 6, 2025. It also contained allegations mentioning the proposed additional defendants and events said to connect them to the original subject matter. Whether those allegations were legally sufficient is a distinct question from whether they existed in the document.

August 24, 2026 · Poling’s order on amendment. The court did recognize that the vehicle claims had been reserved for a separate action. It nevertheless denied amendment on multiple stated grounds, including the sufficiency and connection of proposed new allegations. The court said it had reviewed motions, responses, and supplemental filings. It would therefore be inaccurate to claim the order adopted counsel’s particular product-liability description or to presume that the court did not review any reconstructed paper.

THE STILL-UNRESOLVED VERSION QUESTION: The petitioner maintains that a November 8, 2025 reconstructed First Amended Complaint was submitted after the court required revised citations and pleadings. Yet counsel’s August 10 attachment bears the earlier October 6 date. Independent comparison of the filed versions and the materials actually considered by the court is required before attributing an improper motive or an effect on the decision.

The evidence matters more than rhetoric: Was the position advanced by counsel an accurate characterization of his own attachment? And did the amendment ruling assess the correct, completed pleading and particularized claims? These are record-comparison questions. This analysis does not establish intentional falsification, judicial misconduct, or that amendment was legally required. The underlying confidential domestic-relations materials are not published here.


GO DEEPER ONLY IF YOU WANT TO.

The long chronology, source concordances and legal-analysis pages are still here. They are no longer the front door.

Editorial standard: A discrepancy is not a misconduct finding. The documents control. Allegations, judicial findings, later corrections and competing explanations are labeled separately. If a source disproves our framing, the source wins.