INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM · RALEIGH COUNTY, WEST VIRGINIA

THE RALEIGH RECORD

RALEIGH COUNTY JUDICIAL & LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT

THE REPORTING DESK · PUBLIC WORKING EDITION — SOURCE CHECKS ONGOING

Investigations

A public record cannot be evaluated by headline alone. Each investigation begins with a precise question and an inventory of source documents.

Editorial status: This public investigative desk is under active development. Reports and source descriptions remain subject to verification; no allegation is an adjudicated finding. The Blume petition and six public-release appendix volumes are now available in the dedicated Supreme Court petitions reading room. Original Poling source facsimiles remain subject to separate source-by-source review.

Inaugural series: The Poling Booth

The source program focuses initially on CC-41-2025-C-328 and the two Rule 17 proceedings involving Judge Darl W. Poling. The controlling materials are a docket-reconciled chronology, judicial correspondence and administrative orders, motions and their actual prayers, native-source hearing communications where available, and original order/pleading versions. The question is how the judicial record was created, corrected, described and reviewed—not whether disagreement with a ruling establishes wrongdoing.

Story fileResearch questionStage
Rule 17: the paper trailWhat was transmitted to the Chief Justice, filed with the circuit clerk, served and finally decided in April and August?Public working source article released; attachment and service audit remain outstanding.
Hearings requestedHow do recorded contacts and docketed requests compare with later characterizations? Which requested hearings were actually set or held?Source matrix ready for native recording and motion verification.
Which amended complaint?What changed after the November 2025 court-directed reconstruction, and which version appeared in the August 2026 opposition and order?Version comparison outlined; originals and stamps to pin down.
The show-cause dispositionWhich order, if any, was linked to August 24 docket #134’s notation on the May 8 motion?Order identity/service unresolved; no merits conclusion.
Evidence accepted and describedWhat authorized inventory shows the court received from a restricted submission, and how was it described in an order?RESTRICTED. Source review without upload of sealed evidence.
Filing accessWhat do orders provide about separate-case captions, electronic filing and advance permission for oversized filings?Procedural sources identified; legal/context review pending.

Companion reporting tracks

Counsel on the Record

A future attorney-accountability series will place exact representations next to their claimed source passages, record any actual disciplinary decisions separately from mere complaints, and seek a meaningful response. Example research leads include the difference between asserted economic loss and a later revenue characterization, and the distinction between claims reserved in a pleading and claims actually brought. These are comparison leads, not findings that counsel acted dishonestly or unlawfully.

Court access and record preservation

Develop a separate account of hearing requests, court-ordered reconstruction, case-specific filing controls, denied electronic filing, and record-supplementation procedures. The legal rules and actual dates must be independently checked, and the experiences reported in disability-access grievances are attributed allegations; private medical information is not required for the public to understand procedural questions.

Reporting pipeline: what remains before any story may be released

GateRequired work
Source integrityComplete original, provenance, accurate OCR/transcript, docket and entry dates, signed and served versions.
Document contextFull surrounding passage, contemporaneous filings, contrary records and later decisions.
Legal and privacy screeningSealing/protective orders, case confidentiality, private identifiers, privilege and permissible redaction.
Right of responsePut the actual proposed factual reporting question to identified subjects; retain response and correct errors.
Editorial reviewLabel allegation vs finding; avoid imputing intent; test headline against evidence; explicit owner approval before changing any draft status.

Working source map: See the separate draft Timeline for dated docket entries, Case Files for case boundaries and dispositions, and Evidence Vault for source IDs and restricted-material handling. They are research tools, not publication-ready public archives.