THE REPORTING DESK · PUBLIC WORKING EDITION — SOURCE CHECKS ONGOING
Investigations
A public record cannot be evaluated by headline alone. Each investigation begins with a precise question and an inventory of source documents.
Editorial status: This public investigative desk is under active development. Reports and source descriptions remain subject to verification; no allegation is an adjudicated finding. The Blume petition and six public-release appendix volumes are now available in the dedicated Supreme Court petitions reading room. Original Poling source facsimiles remain subject to separate source-by-source review.
Inaugural series: The Poling Booth
The source program focuses initially on CC-41-2025-C-328 and the two Rule 17 proceedings involving Judge Darl W. Poling. The controlling materials are a docket-reconciled chronology, judicial correspondence and administrative orders, motions and their actual prayers, native-source hearing communications where available, and original order/pleading versions. The question is how the judicial record was created, corrected, described and reviewed—not whether disagreement with a ruling establishes wrongdoing.
| Story file | Research question | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| Rule 17: the paper trail | What was transmitted to the Chief Justice, filed with the circuit clerk, served and finally decided in April and August? | Public working source article released; attachment and service audit remain outstanding. |
| Hearings requested | How do recorded contacts and docketed requests compare with later characterizations? Which requested hearings were actually set or held? | Source matrix ready for native recording and motion verification. |
| Which amended complaint? | What changed after the November 2025 court-directed reconstruction, and which version appeared in the August 2026 opposition and order? | Version comparison outlined; originals and stamps to pin down. |
| The show-cause disposition | Which order, if any, was linked to August 24 docket #134’s notation on the May 8 motion? | Order identity/service unresolved; no merits conclusion. |
| Evidence accepted and described | What authorized inventory shows the court received from a restricted submission, and how was it described in an order? | RESTRICTED. Source review without upload of sealed evidence. |
| Filing access | What do orders provide about separate-case captions, electronic filing and advance permission for oversized filings? | Procedural sources identified; legal/context review pending. |
Companion reporting tracks
Counsel on the Record
A future attorney-accountability series will place exact representations next to their claimed source passages, record any actual disciplinary decisions separately from mere complaints, and seek a meaningful response. Example research leads include the difference between asserted economic loss and a later revenue characterization, and the distinction between claims reserved in a pleading and claims actually brought. These are comparison leads, not findings that counsel acted dishonestly or unlawfully.
Court access and record preservation
Develop a separate account of hearing requests, court-ordered reconstruction, case-specific filing controls, denied electronic filing, and record-supplementation procedures. The legal rules and actual dates must be independently checked, and the experiences reported in disability-access grievances are attributed allegations; private medical information is not required for the public to understand procedural questions.
Reporting pipeline: what remains before any story may be released
| Gate | Required work |
|---|---|
| Source integrity | Complete original, provenance, accurate OCR/transcript, docket and entry dates, signed and served versions. |
| Document context | Full surrounding passage, contemporaneous filings, contrary records and later decisions. |
| Legal and privacy screening | Sealing/protective orders, case confidentiality, private identifiers, privilege and permissible redaction. |
| Right of response | Put the actual proposed factual reporting question to identified subjects; retain response and correct errors. |
| Editorial review | Label allegation vs finding; avoid imputing intent; test headline against evidence; explicit owner approval before changing any draft status. |
Working source map: See the separate draft Timeline for dated docket entries, Case Files for case boundaries and dispositions, and Evidence Vault for source IDs and restricted-material handling. They are research tools, not publication-ready public archives.