THE PUBLICATION · HOW WE WORK
About & Editorial Standards
Don’t take our word for it. Read the record.
The Raleigh Record is an independent judicial and legal accountability publishing project focused initially on Raleigh County, West Virginia. Its purpose is to make complex proceedings intelligible through source documents, rigorous chronology, clear attribution, and an opportunity for meaningful response. It is not a court, a disciplinary authority, or a substitute for legal representation.
Our editorial commitments
1. Identify what the source actually establishes
We identify each material document by issuing body or source, case number where lawfully disclosable, date, document type, and page or passage when available. A filed allegation is evidence that an allegation was made; filing alone does not prove its truth. A docket entry establishes what the docket records, not necessarily every event that occurred outside it.
2. Distinguish facts, claims, and interpretation
Reports distinguish verifiable procedural events, allegations attributed to identified parties, judicial findings, legal analysis, commentary, and open questions. We do not describe contested wrongdoing as an established finding without an appropriate basis. Where records conflict, we explain the competing sources and limitations.
3. Give context and a meaningful opportunity to respond
Before releasing a report focused on an identifiable person, the publication aims to put material factual concerns to that person or an appropriate representative, provide a reasonable opportunity for comment, and include relevant responses accurately. A refusal or lack of response is not proof that an allegation is true.
4. Review legal restrictions and protect private information
Before publication, review sealing orders, protective orders, confidentiality rules, copyright, and privacy implications. Do not upload restricted domestic-violence or personal-safety-order records, sealed evidence, children’s identifying details, personal addresses, financial identifiers, or medical information merely because a copy is available. Redact where lawful and necessary; some materials must not be published at all. An online file may become accessible through a direct URL even if a page is hidden.
5. Preserve an accurate correction trail
Material corrections should identify what changed and when. Reports should be updated when later rulings, newly authenticated evidence, or subject responses materially alter the account. See the separate Corrections & Right of Response policy when it becomes available.
Document and report labels
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Source document | Identified record with provenance noted; authenticity and contents should not be conflated. |
| Allegation | A claim attributed to a person or filing, not adopted as fact merely because it was submitted. |
| Judicial finding | A finding in a specified decision, identified with date, court, and procedural status. |
| Analysis | The publication’s reasoning, explicitly distinguished from underlying documents. |
| Opinion / satire | Clearly labeled commentary, not presented as a factual determination. |
How a report is assembled
Our intended reporting sequence is: define a question; gather the original record and docket context; authenticate sources where possible; identify contradictions and alternative explanations; review restrictions; seek response; provide precise citations; and update the record when needed. A missing document is described as missing or not obtained, not presumed destroyed or withheld deliberately.
Independence and disclosure
Where a contributor has personally participated in the proceedings under examination, relevant involvement and potential conflicts should be disclosed prominently in the resulting report. The website’s project name does not imply affiliation with a court, government body, nonprofit organization, or professional disciplinary authority.